Skip to content
GuidesReview

The Keys of Glasner's Achievement and Why The Palace Tactical Approach Could Struggle in Adaptation At Other Clubs

Some matches seem out of place. Maybe it’s almost conceivable that, had things gone a bit otherwise in the 70s, Malcolm Allison could have been coaching their side beyond the Soviet Bloc for a shot against Valeriy Lobanovskyi’s tactical masterminds, but a match between Dynamo Kyiv and Crystal Palace remains a fixture that provokes a second look. It seems like a category error: how can those two clubs possibly be in the same tournament?

However this is the modern world. Ukraine is battling invasion, its teams diminished. The English top flight is incredibly wealthy. And Crystal Palace are managed by among the emerging stars of the European game. They not only face off on Thursday, but they won with a notable comfort. It was their third consecutive victory, their 19th consecutive game without loss.

Managerial Speculation and Next Moves

Therefore, because no mid-size club can even just be permitted to savor a winning streak, all the talk is of which club the Austrian manager could go next. His contract expires at the conclusion of the campaign and he has refused to agree to an extension. He is 51; if he is going to take over a top club with the possibility of an extended tenure in charge, he lacks a great deal of time to secure a move. Could he then be the solution for the Red Devils? He does, after all, utilize the identical formation as the Sporting coach, just significantly more successfully.

Tactical Formation and Cultural Context

This brings up the issue of why a system that has attracted so much scepticism at United works so effectively at Selhurst Park. But it’s not just about the formation, nor is it the case – within reason – that one formation is intrinsically superior than another. Rather certain tactical shapes, in conjunction with the manner they are enacted, prioritise certain aspects of play. It is, at the minimum, intriguing that since the manager’s Everton claimed the championship in 1962-63 with a W-M, only one side has secured the Premier League playing with a back three: the Italian’s Blues in 2016-17.

Antonio Conte’s team clinched the championship in 2016-17 with a three defenders and effectively two No 10s.

That success was something of a rare event. Chelsea that campaign had no European football, allowing them fresher than their competitors, and they had players who suited the system virtually freakishly perfectly.

N’Golo Kanté, with his endurance and reading of the game, is almost two players, and he was functioning at the base of midfield alongside the steadying influence of Cesc Fàbregas or Nemanja Matic, one of the most incisive playmakers the Premier League has seen. That offered the platform for the dual playmakers: the Belgian wizard, who thrived in his unrestricted role, and the Spanish forward, a master of the run into the box. Every one of those players was enhanced by their partnership with the teammates.

Systemic Reasons and Strategic Difficulties

To an extent, the relative absence of success for the three-man defense, at minimum in terms of winning titles, is cultural. Not many teams have secured the title using a back three because few clubs have played a three-at-the-back system. The World Cup victory in the 1960s cemented in the national mindset the efficacy of defensive organization with a four defenders.

This stayed the default, almost without challenge, for the twenty years that followed. But there could also be particular strategic reasons. A back three derives its breadth from the wingbacks; it could be that the intense hard-running nature of the English game makes the requirement on those players excessive to be maintained regularly.

But the 3-4-2-1 presents particular difficulties. It is solid, offering the trapezoid structure – three center-backs shielded by two holders – that is commonly recognised as the most effective way to guard against opposition counterattacks. But that is only one phase of the game. If they advance forward from the protection of the triple centre‑backs, given the common use of formations with a central trio, a pair of central midfielders will tend to be outmanned without support from elsewhere – unless a single player has the exceptional gifts of Kanté.

The striker rejoices after netting his side’s second strike against Dynamo Kyiv.

Advantages and Weaknesses of the Approach

The very stability of that tight 3-2 shape, additionally, while an benefit for a team aiming to absorb attacks, turns into a possible drawback for a side that seek to take the game to the opposition. Its biggest strength is also its primary flaw. The rigid nature of the system, the way the midfield is divided into holders and creators – exclusively defensive mids and No 10s in modern terminology, with zero box-to-box midfielders – means that without a player to move between lines there is a risk of being read easily; again, the Blues had the perfect player to do that, David Luiz often advancing ahead from the back three to act as an extra midfield presence.

Divergent Styles at Palace and Old Trafford

Crystal Palace aren’t concerned about possession. They have the second-lowest possession of any side in the top division. It’s not their role to have the ball. And that is the primary explanation why a direct contrast with United’s difficulties is challenging. United, by tradition and by demand, can not be the team with the second-lowest possession in the Premier League.

Although they opted to counterattack against opposing elite sides, most of their matches will be against rivals who sit deep and would be happy enough with a draw. In the bulk of fixtures there is an pressure on them to dominate the ball.

Maybe a progressive team could play a 3-4-2-1 but it demands very particular personnel – as the Italian coach possessed at Stamford Bridge. The Austrian’s success with it has arrived at Lask and Eintracht Frankfurt, where he has been in a position to have his side defend compactly and break at pace.

Palace have beaten West Ham and West Ham, because most sides do at the moment, frustrated Chelsea, and torn the Reds to pieces on the break. But they’ve also drawn at home to Sunderland and Nottingham Forest, and struggled to beat the Norwegian side. Sit deep against them and they have difficulty for invention.

Adaptation and Future Possibilities

Could the manager adapt if he moved

The writer

Dr. Deborah Hill

Elara is a seasoned writer and researcher passionate about sharing practical knowledge and innovative ideas with readers worldwide.

GuidesReview

Type to search articles.